HomeMy WebLinkAboutSCMinutes_2022_05_11City of Brookings
Sustainability Council Meeting Minutes
Wednesday, May 11, 2022 4:00 PM Virtual
Sustainability Council Members: Bruce Pengra, Cynthia Kunkel,Ben Vukovich,Louis Hesler, Albert Patin,
Samuel Krueger, Anthony Shanks, Robin Buterbaugh, Betty Beer, Emily Abele, Kiley Rath, and SDSU Student
Representative Gabrielle Bolwerk. City Staff: Jacob Meshke, Assistant City Manager.
1 Call to Order
E. Abele
2. Approval of the Agenda
Moved for approval: B. Beer Second: R. Buterbaugh
Aye: All Opposed: None
3. Approval of the Minutes
Moved for approval: R. Buterbaugh Second: B. Beer
Aye: All Opposed: None
4. Open Forum
●B. Beer: Brookings Sunshine Sustainability group will be receiving their transportation report
soon.
●R. Buterbaugh: BSC will host a booth and table at the upcoming McCrory garden event -
any further input? Additional items to be added to the table?
○E. Abele: Annual report, strategic plan, printed copies along with climate stickers.
○B. Beer: Hard copy of fabric recycling presentation (at least one copy)
●R. Buterbaugh: Final draft of the bioretention sign is complete - moving forward with printing
and installing at the site.
5. Front Yard Gardens – Mike Struck, Community Development Director
Spoke on the currently and proposed zoning ordancesses dealing with front
yard gardens and landscaped areas within a yard devoted for the growing of
controlled shrubbery and plants.
●As a college town the city deals with many rental homes and lack of
parking spaces. Many rental homes have tried to convert lawn areas
into parking areas, the ordinances are put in place to prevent this from
happening, ordinances have also been created for the backyard to
prevent large areas from being converted into gravel parking lots.
Balancing these ordinances with the wishes of the city residents can
be difficult.
●In regard to creating gardens on front lawns there are concerns with
dust control, run-off to city property, and unsightly exposed areas
during the dormant seasons.
○Ways to prevent public complaints include controlled height
and proper maintenance along with a buffer strip separating
the garden from the sidewalk.
○Flower gardens are exempt from these ordinances as they are
considered more of a landscaping feature.
●A couple items of the new ordinance would include:
○Changing the existing 15” max height for plants on the front
lawn to a reduced 8”
○Giving the parks and recreation department the authority to
designate no mow areas under the discretion of the director.
These now mow areas would still be maintained by the city as
far as controlling noxious weeds, but would exist as large
areas of longer grass with intermittent mowing.
●Tuesday May 24th there will be a public reading of the proposed new
ordinance.
●Comments from BSC:
●R. Buterbaugh brought up a discussion about making room for initiatives such as no-mow
May within this new ordinance. Continuing with discussions on exemptions from the
ordinance, in regards to native grasses, and sustainable factors related to lawn care and
gardening.
●B. Beer suggested a motion to support the currently proposed ordinance with a continued
discussion on amendments regarding items such as native grasses, no-mow May and
other exemptions.
Moved: B. Beer Second: R. Buterbaugh
Aye: All Opposed: None
6. Fabric Recycling Presentation – Albert Patin
Albert Patin organized the presentation into six main areas:
1.Recognizing the source material used within the study.
2.Overall carbon emission due to the industry on the global scale
a.4% of total carbon emissions are due to textiles
b.The fashion industry produces 1.2 million tone of Co2 per year.
3.Garments put into landfills
a.Single / minimal use due to fashion industry
b.Discarded clothing is the main source of textile waste in the US
landfills.
4.Choice of materials used in textile production and how they affect the
recyclability of the clothing items.
a.Polyester made from fossil fuels - 70 million barrels of oil used
each year. When washed poly clothing sheds microplastics in
the wastewater resulting in pollution.
b.Blended together materials creates textile which are harder to
recycle as they are more time consuming and require a labor
intensive and skilled workforce.
5.Challenges
a.In general studies show that we are buying more and using
less.
b.Recycling rate of textiles is roughly 14.7 percent (less than 1%
produced)
6.Opportunities to reduce textile waste
a.Brands and retailers have a strong influence. Think of was to
get the factories and material producers on board and
engaged in the recycling process of tectiles.
b.As citizens we can purchase second hand clothing items
c.Learn proper care to increase leng gevigy of clothing items
d.Reacquaint ourselves with unused clothing items we have
forgotten.
e.Donate and consign with local options
7. City Update
Fun fact: the city building is a storm shelter available for the public and their pets during weather
emergencies.
Introduction of new members:
Tony shanks
Kiley Rath
Gabi Bolwerk
8. Growing Sustainable Communities Conference Attendees and Possible Action
(Discussion postponed due to lack of time)
9. Review Climate Action Plan Research Findings and Possible Action 10. Solid 10. Waste
Master Plan RFP Selection Committee Appointment
●Working on selecting a committee for master plan development, would like the input of a
BAC member, Albert Patin recommended by J. Meshke.
Motion to appoint A. Patin as the BSC representative to the Waste Water Master Plan.
Moved: R. Buterbaugh Second: B. Beer
Aye: All Opposed: None
11. Virtual Meetings
(Discussion postponed due to lack of time)
12. Updates/Reports from Subcommittees
a. Marketing and Communication
b. Waste
c. Energy
d. Local Foods
13. Updates from Liaisons
a. Bicycle Committee
b. Human Rights Commission
c. CLEAR
14. Call for Future Agenda Items
B. Beer: Electric buses / transportation (July?)
15. Adjourn
Motion to Adjourn
Moved: A. B. Beer Second: S. Krueger
Aye: All Opposed: None
Respectfully Submitted: Samuel Krueger