The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2024 BOE Minutes 391 Board of Equalization Hearings Local - Brookings City and School Thursday, March 21, 2024 The local Board of Equalization for the City of Brookings met at 9:00 a.m. on Thursday, March 21, 2024 in the Brookings City & County Government Center. (A quorum of members was not able to be obtained for Monday, March 18`' as identified in SDCL 10-1 1-13.) The following members were present: Deputy Mayor Nick Wendell; City Council Members Wayne Avery, Brianna Doran, and Bonny Specker; and School Board Member Teresa Binkley. Jacob Brehmer, Equalization Office Director, Reid Squires, Deputy Equalization Director, and Bonnie Foster, City Clerk were also present. Deputy Mayor Nick Wendell called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m. The following appeals were heard by the Local Board: No. 01: Michael Moriarty Moriarty Third Addition, Lot 4 & S, and 566 feet of West 90 feet of West 90 feet of Lot 3, Block 2 (703 8"' St. So.) Parcel: 40380-00200-004-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $60,100 $493,000 $553,100 A ellant's Request $60,100 $339,900 $400,000 Board's Decision $60,100 $493,000 $553,100 A motion was made by Specker, seconded by Avery, for the valuation to remain at $60,100 on the land, and $493,000 on the building, for a total of$553,100. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 02: Michael Moriarty Moriarty Third Addition, Lot 5, Block I 510 7 h Ave. So. Parcel: 40380-00100-005-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $43,600 $956,200 $999,800 A ellant's Request $43,600 $756,400 $800000 Board's Decision $43,600 $956,200 $999,800 A motion was made by Specker, seconded by Doran, for the valuation to remain at$43,600 on the land, and $956,200 on the building, for a total of$999,800. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 03: Michael Moriarty Moriarty Fourth Addition, Lot IA, Block 3 1830 8 St. So. Parcel: 40381-00300-001-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $106,300 $930,600 $1,036,900 A ellant's Request $106,300 $693,700 $800,000 Board's Decision $106,300 $930,600 $1,036,900 A motion was made by Binkley, seconded by Doran, for the valuation to remain at$106,300 on the land, and $930,600 on the building, for a total of$1,036,900. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 04: Michael Moriarty Moriarty Fourth Addition, Lot 2A, Block 3 829 Park Ave. Parcel: 40381-00300-002-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $134,200 $1,023,000 $1,157,200 A ellant's Request $134,200 $695,800 $830*000 Board's Decision $134,200 $1,023,000 $1,157,200 A motion was made by Doran, seconded by Specker, for the valuation to remain at $134,200 on the land, and $1,023,000 on the building, for a total of$1,157,200. All members voted yes; motion carried. 392 No. 05: Michael Moriarty Moriarty Fourth Addition, Lot 3A, Block 3 839 Park Ave. Parcel: 40381-00300-003-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $149,800 $975,000 $1,124,800 A ellant's Request $149,800 $700200 $850,000 Board's Decision $149,800 $975,000 $1,124,800 A motion was made by Avery, seconded by Specker, for the valuation to remain at $149,800 on the land, and $975,000 on the building, for a total of$1,124,800. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 06: Paul E. Moriarty Moriarty Ed ebrook Addition, Lot 15, Block 9 2003-2015 201h St. So. Parcel: 40372-00900-015-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $544,700 $4,443,200 $4,987,900 A ellant's Request $544700 $3,0559000 $3,599,700 Board's Decision $544,700 $4,443,200 $4,987,900 A motion was made by Doran, seconded by Specker, for the valuation to remain at $544,700 on the land, and $4,443,200 on the building, for a total of$4,987,900. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 07: Paul E. Moriarty Moriarty Ed ebrook Addition, Lot 7, Block I 701 W. 13`h St. Parcel: 40375-00100-007-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $472,600 $477,900 $950,500 A ellant's Request $362,000 $191,400 $553#400 Board's Decision $472,600 $477,900 $950,500 A motion was made by Specker, seconded by Doran, for the valuation to remain at $472,600 on the land, and $477,900 on the building, for a total of$950,500. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 08: Paul E. Moriarty Indian Hills Addition, Lots 4-5-6, Onaka Village 817 Onaka Trail Parcel: 40265-01000-004-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $63,000 $459,400 $522,400 Appellants Request $63,000 $322,500 $385500 Board's Decision $63,000 $325,840 1 $388,840 A motion was made by Binkley, seconded by Specker, for the valuation to remain at $63,200 on the land, and change the building to $325,840, for a total of$388,840. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 09: Paul E. Moriarty Henry's Addition, Lots 7-8, Block 2 705 Main Ave. Parcel: 40235-00200-007-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $49,500 $378,000 $427,500 A ellant's Request $49,500 $227,400 $276,900 Board's Decision $49,500 $243,960 1 $293,460 A motion was made by Specker, seconded by Avery, for the valuation to remain at $49,500 on the land, and change the building to $243,960, for a total of$293,460. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 10: Paul E. Moriarty Moriarty Fourth Addition, Lot 2 and South 40 feet of Lot I, Block 2 (830-840-844 Park Ave. Parcel: 40381-00200-002-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $284,900 $2,236,900 $2,521,800 A ellant's Request $284,900 $1,241,800 $1526,700 Board's Decision $284,900 $2,236,900 $2,521,800 A motion was made by Binkley, seconded by Specker, for the valuation to remain at $284,900 on the land, and $2,236,900 on the building, for a total of$2,521,800. All members voted yes; motion carried. 393 No. 1 1: Paul E. Moriarty Randi Petersons Addition, West 132 feet of Lot 4, and all of Lot 5, Block 2 (716 Medary Ave. Parcel: 40500-00200-005-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $44,600 $381,100 $425,700 A ellant's Request $449600 $300,500 $345 .10.0. Board's Decision $44,600 $381,100 $425,700 A motion was made by Doran, seconded by Avery, for the valuation to remain at $44,600 on the land, and $381,100 on the building, for a total of$425,700. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 12: Paul E. Moriarty Randi Petersons Addition, Lot 6, Block 2 722 Medary Ave. Parcel: 40500-00200-006-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $24,800 $209,400 $234,200 A ellant's Request $24,800 $148,400 173920011 Board's Decision $24,800 $209,400 $234,200 A motion was made by Doran, seconded by Binkley, for the valuation to remain at $24,800 on the land, and $209,400 on the building, for a total of$234,200. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 13: Paul E. Moriarty Randi Peterson Addition, Lots 7-8, Block 2 726 M dary Ave. Parcel: 40500-00200-008-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $49,500 $480,500 $530,000 A ellant's Request $49,500` $307,400 $356900 Board's Decision $49,500 $480,500 $530,000 A motion was made by Specker, seconded by Doran, for the valuation to remain at $49,500 on the land, and $480,500 on the building, for a total of$530,000. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 14: Paul E. Moriarty Randi Peterson Addition, Lots 12-13, Block 2 717 11 Ave. Parcel: 40500-00200-012-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $49,500 $469,500 $519,000 A ellant's Request $49,500 $300,900 $3509'400' Board's Decision $49,500 $469,500 $519,000 A motion was made by Doran, seconded by Avery, for the valuation to remain at$49,500 on the land, and $469,500 on the building, for a total of$519,000. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 15: Paul E. Moriarty Moriarty Third Addition, Lot 4, Block I 534 7`' Ave. So. Parcel: 40380-00100-004-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $52,000 $886,800 $938,800 A ellant's Request $52,000 $678,600 $730600 Board's Decision $52,000 $886,800 $938:800 A motion was made by Doran, seconded by Specker, for the valuation to remain at $52,000 on the land, and $886,800 on the building, for a total of$938,800. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 16: Paul E. Moriarty Petersons Second Addition, Lots 3-4-5, Block 8 614 Harvey Dunn St Parcel: 40455-00800-003-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $108,000 $788,300 $896,300 Appellanes Request $108,000 $4389500 $54b;500 Board's Decision 1 $108,000 1 $684,605 $792,605 A motion was made by Doran, seconded by Avery, for the valuation to remain at$108,000 on the land, and $684,605 on the building, for a total of$792,605. All members voted yes; motion carried. 394 No. 17: Paul E. Moriarty Henry's Addition, West 78 feet of South 190 feet of Lot 10, East 59 feet of Lot 15, Block 2 229 r St. Parcel: 40235-00200-015-10 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $32,500 $705,500 $738,000 A ellant's Request $329500 $455,500 $4889000 Board's Decision 1 $32,500 $575,480 $607,980 A motion was made by Specker, seconded by Binkley, for the valuation to remain at $32,500 on the land, and $575,480 on the building, for a total of$607,980. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 18: Paul E. Moriarty Moriarty Third Addition, Lots I, 2, 5, and Lot 3, exc South 66 feet of West 90 feet, Block 2 71 1 8`" St. So. Parcel: 40380-00200-00 1-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $198,000 $1,517,100 $1,715,100 A ellant's Request $198,000 $1,383,500 $1,581,500 Board's Decision $198,000 $1,517,100 $1,715,100 A motion was made by Binkley, seconded by Doran, for the valuation to remain at $198,000 on the land, and $1,517,000 on the building, for a total of$1,715,000. All members voted yes; motion carried. No. 19: Paul E. Moriarty Moriarty Addition, Block 1 (525-535 Elm Ave., 601-61 1 Elm Ave., 508-518 Heritage Dr., 524- 534 Heritage Dr., 600-610 Heritage Dr., and 1418-1428 5 h St. So. Parcel: 40370-00100-000-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $234,000 $1,593,800 $1,827,800 A ellant's Request $234,000 :$1,472 800 $'j j06j800 Board's Decision $234,000 $1,593,800 $1,827,800 A motion was made by Binkley, seconded by Specker, for the valuation to remain at $234,000 on the land, and $1,593,800 on the building, for a total of$1,827,800. All members voted yes; motion carried. The following Equalization Office corrections were reviewed: Equalization Office Corrections: A motion was made by City Council Member Specker, seconded by City Council Member Doran, to approve the following Equalization Office corrections: No. 01: Suann D Aho Reserve Second Addition, Lot 33, Block 9 1402 Bluestem Path Parcel: 40504-009-00-033-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $45,000 $514,500 $559,500 Equalization Office Request $45,000 $349,800 $394,800 Board's Decision $45,000 $349,800 1 $394,800 No. 02: VK Properties LLC Camelot Square Addition, Lot 26, and the North 20 feet of Lots 25, Block I (1 106 Christine Ave. Parcel: 40090-00100-026-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $34,400 $284,400 $318,800 Equalization Office Request $34,400 $245,000 $279,400 Board's Decision 1 $34,400 $245,000 1 $279,400 No. 03: Bret P Enderson EtUx Americana Addition, Lot I A, Block 2 2018 Constitution Blvd. Parcel: 40014-00200-00 1-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $69,000 $679,900 $748,900 Equalization Office Request $69000 $587800 $656800 Board's Decision $69,000 $587,800 1 $656,800 395 No. 04: Mahalohana II LLC Reserve Third Addition, Block 1 1515-1525-1522-1538-1608-1622 Ohana Ave. Parcel: 40501-00 100-000-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $624,700 $3,695,600 $4,320,300 Equalization Office Request $624700 $3,079,500 $3704;200`` Board's Decision $624,700 $3,079,500 $3,704,200 No. 05: Flats at Neill Park LLC Prairie Hills Addition, Lot 2, Block 19 525 Sweet rass Dr. Parcel: 40473-01900-002-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $545,500 $4,653,000 $5,198,500 Equalization Office Request $545,500 $0 $545;500 Board's Decision $545,500 $0 $545,500 No. 06: Flats at Neill Park LLC Prairie Hills Addition, Block 20A 12123 Tall Grass Parkway) Parcel: 40473-02000-000-05 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $548,900 $4,701,200 $5,250,100 Equalization Office Request $548,900 $0 $548900 Board's Decision 1 $548,900 $0 $548,900 No. 07: Sodak Ace LLC Southland Addition, Lot I, Block 4 21 13 Ace Ave. Parcel: 40582-00400-001-00 LAND BUILDING TOTAL 2024 County Valuation $73,800 $415,300 $489,100 Equalization Office Request $73,800 $0' $73;'800n ' Board's Decision $73,800 $0 $73,800 All present voted yes; motion carried. A motion was made by Binkley, seconded by Specker to adjourn. The hearin was adjourned at 12:00 noon. Of P ti1 _ate;'CN`°w'•' pi(,,/(�C e� io' M e 9 nnie Foster, City Clerk '+1,1��waa?H OP�G J